Thursday, November 16, 2006

 

More Terminology

Normally I assume small letters, however, our authentication system allows users to use capitals in the password. In one case, a customer asked repeatedly for "small caps". It went something like this:

"That's small caps"
"Uh... Small letters and capital letters are different things. Did you want small letters or capital letters?"
"Small caps"
"No, it has to be one or the other. Which did you want?"
"Small caps"
"Small caps are when you have capital letters that have had the size scaled down. You can't type those. Small letters are also referred to as lowercase letters. Capital letters are big letters, also referred to as uppercase letters. Your only choices are 'small' or 'capital'. Which would you like?"

To help you appreciate just how absurd this is, I've invented a similar conversation:

"Would you like fries with that?"
"Yes no."
"Uh... Is that a yes or a no?"
"Yes no"
"Sir, you have to choose one of them"
"Yes no"
"No, you don't get it. 'Yes' is an affirmative response, 'no' is a negative response, and according to the law of the excluded middle, you can't respond with both!" *clerk's head explodes*

Clearly the customer is a master of Zen Buddhism and/or logical systems with more than 2 truth values. Or perhaps he actually wanted SMALL CAPS. Though this would of course make you wonder how he planned to type the password.

If you've learned to speak idiot by now, you may accurately have concluded by now that it was neither of the above. He wanted small letters. The worst part is that I've heard multiple people refer to small letters as small caps. Now I'm not normally too picky about mistakes creeping into the public lexicon, but seriously... Can we TRY to keep out mistakes that directly contradict the proper meaning? Or is it just that we "could care less"? Sigh.

Comments:
Could you mean 'Law of non-contradiction' instead, which states that something can't be both true and not true? The 'Law of the excluded middle' is that something is true or it's negation is true. Been a while since I took this...
 
From the Wikipedia entry on the law of the excluded middle: 'the law of the excluded middle states that a proposition is either true or false... it is literally translated as "a third is not given."'

While there are undoubtedly rare and pedantic philosophical situations where the law of non-contradiction and the law of the excluded middle are not exactly the same thing, as far as this situation goes, it really doesn't matter.

Having said that, in the spirit of pedantry, it is worth noting that the conjunction of the original two is still a third answer, and thus still forbidden by the LotR... I mean LotEM. ;)
 
Oh for the love of... Yeah you're right. Watch these:

http://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/einsteinjokes/
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?